free web page counters
5 Responsed To This Post
mygif_alt
Jay Neely Says, in 5-21-2007 at 18:04:51 from 24.147.221.165    

The main argument here seems to be that by automatically causing a desktop application to take action when they encounter microformat data, Firefox 3 poses a security risk by allowing this. But that isn't what the quoted material from Alex Faaborg says. It states:
"future Web browsers are likely going to associate semantically marked up data you encounter on the Web with specific applications".

Association does *not* imply automatic action. What it means is that if I come across a phone number with microformat tags around it, I can put my mouse over it, right click(PC user) and use the context menu to select an option like "Add this number to my Skype phonebook".

Your other statement is that microformats are a privacy risk by "broadcasting" personal information. In actuality, not much more so than the vast amount of our personal data already online today, even without special formatting. And clearly, use of microformats is a choice.

Finally, both microformats and Firefox 3 are still under development. This kind of un-researched speculative worrying should be posted on a development forum, where it could be shot down or corrected, depending on how nice the other users are.

mygif
anon Says, in 5-21-2007 at 20:00:29 from 76.19.196.140    

That's not the point. Consider the incentive this would offer extension authors to bundle malware with their extensions. Yes, as soon as each such instance was found it would be exposed, but that's not a good reason to encourage that situation.

mygif_alt
Vincent Says, in 5-22-2007 at 09:59:31 from 80.126.159.235    

I'm quite sure that Firefox will not e.g. automatically synchronize your calendar dates with some online calendar. It will probably just notify you that entries are available and can be synced as you wish, but the responsibility still lies with the user, as it already does. Also, I don't see how stealing you personal data would be a risk, as you can decide for yourself what you put in your hCard, just as you decide for yourself to e.g. give your last name on forums.

mygif
Sam Sethi Says, in 5-22-2007 at 12:52:26 from 86.133.53.48    

I can imagine this process working in much the same way as plugins do today with a two-phase trust model. With plugins today you have to first agree to trust the plugin site and only then will any plugin load and even then you still have the option to cancel the plugin.

Well with microformats the model may be reversed. If I post an hcard I might request the person requesting my hCard provide me with some details. Only then will I present my details and only then will we form a link which is how bi-directional SSE could work.

I agree if nothing is done then a simple spider app as proved by http://kitchen.technorati.com could come along and take our details without our premission.

mygif_alt
Craig Francis Says, in 5-23-2007 at 04:29:26 from 82.32.88.140    

I have a feeling that quite a few people are mis-understanding how micro-formats are intended to work.

From a privacy perspective, the data is already published, the micro-formats are simply helping a computer identify the individual parts.

You don't need authentication (Sam)… its like when you right click on an image and using the 'save as' action… but instead of saving the image, you will be adding the contact details to your address book application.

Have a look at this page…

http://www.craigfrancis.co.uk/contact

It's using micro-formats for my address and telephone number… now wouldn't it be great to right-click and add those details to your address book (if you wanted them), instead of having to copy/page each of the parts?

Sorry the comment area are closed or not available for non registered member